| 關於花木蘭 | 聯絡我們 |
各研究系列皆為套書銷售單本不零售
書名:從五體末篇看《史記》的特質──以〈平準〉、〈三王〉、〈今上〉三篇為主
作者:呂世浩
提要

       古人著書,常於篇章首尾有所寓義。而阮芝生先生首言《史記》五體首篇皆寓「貴讓」之意後,對於五體末篇是否亦有寓意,便成為研究上值得注意的問題。本書之目的,在於透過論析書體、世家體、本紀體之末篇作意,及結合前人對表體、列傳體末篇之相關成果,來研究此一主題。

書體末篇是〈平準書〉,其於平準設置之原由,首尾凡敘三十七變,以明天子患貧求利之心日漸急迫,詐力之術輾轉相生而無窮,其極則以「平準」籠天下之利,世風亦因此而大壞。太史公將古今兩次世變,並列於正文及贊語之中,以明世變陵遲之因,在於天子一人之多欲。

        世家體末篇為〈三王世家〉,太史公以編列公文書之作法,欲採武帝及群臣「自供之詞」,以彰武帝讓虛促實、好欲爭利之心。其於正文內不發一言,正可襯托出武帝君臣文辭之「爛然可觀」,又何言哉!

本紀體末篇為〈今上本紀〉,此篇雖亡,然由《史記》各篇對武帝之記述,則不難明太史公之意,在譏刺武帝之所為實與始皇無異。而由〈今上本紀〉亡佚的相關史料來看,此篇極可能為漢廷所刪削。日後《史記‧今上本紀》與《漢書‧武帝紀》一亡一存,實乃因其作意不同所致。

        是故知太史公欲以五體首末對照:以〈五帝〉之公讓,明〈今上〉之私欲;以〈三代〉之非爭貴讓,刺〈漢興〉之德薄私天下;以〈禮書〉之盡性通王,防〈平準〉之爭利不已;以〈吳太伯〉之口不言讓而讓心真誠,譏〈三王〉之讓讓不已而心實欲之;以〈伯夷〉之奔義,諷〈貨殖〉之爭利。然後知撥亂反正之法,惟有「以禮義防於利」。知此寓意,則《史記》「論治之書」、「百王大法」之特質,於是明矣!

目錄
目 次
第一章 前 言········································································································ 1
第二章 平準與世變──書體之末〈平準書〉析論·················································· 5
一、篇章結構解析································································································ 8
二、三十七變與平準··························································································· 11
三、竭財奉上與詐力相生··················································································· 32
四、多欲、多故與反是······················································································· 40
五、平準與世變·································································································· 45
第三章 三王與文辭──世家體之末〈三王世家〉析論········································· 49
一、解析篇章結構······························································································ 50
二、評論〈三王世家〉偽作諸說········································································ 51
三、比較《史》、《漢》及褚〈補〉三王封策····················································· 60
四、從出土〈責寇恩事〉冊論三王世家之真偽················································· 67
五、三王與文辭·································································································· 73
第四章 今上與孝武──本紀體之末〈今上本紀〉討論········································· 83
一、〈今上本紀〉亡佚考····················································································· 84
二、《史記》全書關於「今上」的記載:附〈今上長編〉································ 91
三、太史公心中的「今上」············································································· 205
四、今上與孝武································································································ 222
第五章 結論:從五體之末看《史記》的特質··················································· 229
徵引書目··············································································································· 235