| 關於花木蘭 | 聯絡我們 |
各研究系列皆為套書銷售單本不零售
書名:惠棟《古文尚書考》研究
作者:趙銘豐
提要

         本論文的研究進路包含「緒論」與「結論」共為五章。

         第一章:「緒論」共分三節。第一節將就惠棟《古文尚書考》的研究動機與研究目的發聲。第二節則交代筆者對於惠棟《古文尚書考》的文本結構,與主要參考文獻的交叉分析。第三節則展現個人所持研究方法,對於惠棟《古文尚書考》所進行的三大考辨策略。

        第二章:「惠棟《古文尚書考》文獻徵引的學術價值」共分兩節。第一節將就惠棟《古文尚書考》所徵引的十二則「梅鷟曰」的文獻價值進行平議。第二節則就惠棟《古文尚書考》的「閻君之論」與「間附閻說」,論述閻若璩《疏證》抄本的傳布情況,希望藉此還原惠棟當時所目睹《疏證》的抄本,因為抄寫條件的差異,多少會造成惠棟以及後代學人對於理解閻氏《疏證》的偏差。

        第三章:「惠棟《古文尚書考‧卷上》考證方法」共分兩節。第一節將就考辨方法的「邏輯基點」發聲,說明惠棟如何樹立以「孔氏《古文尚書》五十八篇」與「鄭氏述古文逸《書》二十四篇」作為考辨真《古文尚書》的邏輯基點。第二節則說明惠棟如何在上述兩項前提下,進行「證孔氏逸《書》九條」、「梅氏增多《古文》二十五篇」、「辨梅氏增多《古文》之謬十五條」、「辨《尚書》分篇之謬」等等,由承認漢代真《古文尚書》曾經存世的前提下,所開展出的推理辨證。

        第四章:「惠棟《古文尚書考‧卷下》辨偽舉證」共分兩節。第一節就惠棟《古文尚書考‧卷下》辨偽舉證的隱性重出,彙整出「獨出惠棟」、「惠棟與梅鷟」、「惠棟與閻若璩」、「惠棟、梅鷟、閻若璩」等四個重出組別,說明惠棟考辨《古文尚書》的辨偽舉證與他者的重出比例,並檢驗這四個組別辨偽舉證的的證據效力。

        第五章:「結論」。筆者將就「惠棟《古文尚書考》的成就及其在《古文尚書》考辨史上的學術地位」,提出個人最後的結論。

目錄

 

目 次
第一章 緒 論······································································································· 1
第一節 研究目的與範圍····················································································· 1
第二節 書坊刻書之沿革····················································································· 2
第二章 明代書坊之地理分佈················································································· 5
第一節 北直隸···································································································· 5
第二節 南直隸···································································································· 7
第三節 浙江省·································································································· 12
第四節 福建·································································································· 14
第五節 廣東省及其他地區之書坊···································································· 21
第三章 書板之轉移······························································································ 23
第四章 書籍之盜印與書坊刻書之································································ 27
第五章 明代書價與書籍之流通············································································ 31
第六章 明代書坊刻書一覽表··············································································· 35
第七章 結 論···································································································· 113
附錄一:引用目錄簡稱一覽表·············································································· 115
參考書目··············································································································· 119

 

目 次
序 言 姜廣輝
第一章 緒 論······································································································· 1
第一節 研究動機與研究目的············································································· 1
一、研究動機···································································································· 1
二、研究目的···································································································· 1
第二節 文本結構與文獻回顧的交叉分析··························································· 2
一、成書階段的界定························································································ 2
二、體例與歸納方式························································································ 4
第三節 研究策略釋要························································································· 9
一、彙集梅鷟與閻若璩相關見解的意義·························································· 9
二、考辨方法的邏輯基點及其推理辨證························································· 11
三、辨偽舉證的隱性重出及其證據效力························································· 13
第二章 《古文尚書考》文獻徵引的學術價值····················································· 15
第一節 「梅鷟曰」平議··················································································· 15
一、出處的再商搉·························································································· 15
二、與陳第《尚書疏衍》的關係···································································· 22
三、與梅鷟《尚書考異》的關係···································································· 24
四、結 語············································································································· 27
第二節 「閻君之論」與《尚書古文疏證》抄本的傳布·································· 28
一、抄本「一卷本」······················································································· 28
二、抄本「四卷本」······················································································· 28
三、抄本「五卷本」······················································································· 29
四、抄本「八卷本」······················································································· 40
五、結 語······································································································ 42
第三章 《古文尚書考‧卷上》的考辨方法···························································· 45
第一節 考辨方法的邏輯基點············································································ 45
一、梅鷟的考辨立基······················································································· 45
二、閻若璩的考辨立基··················································································· 48
三、程廷祚的考辨立基··················································································· 50
四、惠棟的考辨立基······················································································· 53
五、結 語······································································································ 57
第二節 考辨方法的推理辨證············································································ 58
一、辨《正義》四條······················································································· 58
二、證孔氏逸《書》九條··············································································· 64
三、「梅氏增多《古文》二十五篇」······························································ 71
四、辨梅氏增多《古文》之謬十五條···························································· 78
五、辨《尚書》分篇之謬··············································································· 99
六、結 語···································································································· 105
第四章 《古文尚書考‧卷下》的辨偽舉證·························································· 107
第一節 辨偽舉證的隱性重出·········································································· 107
一、重出數據統計························································································· 107
二、「惠棟、梅鷟」的重出現象···································································· 108
三、「惠棟、閻若璩」的重出現象································································ 109
四、「惠棟、梅鷟、閻若璩」的重出現象····················································· 110
五、結 語····································································································· 111
第二節 辨偽舉證的證據效力·········································································· 112
一、「獨出惠棟」的舉證效力········································································ 112
二、「惠棟、梅鷟」的重出舉證效力····························································· 119
三、「惠棟、閻若璩」的重出舉證效力························································· 128
四、「惠棟、梅鷟、閻若璩」的重出舉證效力············································· 137
五、結 語···································································································· 146
第五章 結 論···································································································· 147
主要參考書目········································································································ 149
附 錄··················································································································· 157
附錄一 辨偽條目的「典源」暨「按語」······················································· 157
附錄二 「惠棟、梅鷟」的辨偽重出······························································· 179
附錄三 「惠棟、閻若璩」的辨偽重出·························································· 205
附錄四 「惠棟、梅鷟、閻若璩」的辨偽重出··············································· 211